The Eros Association is considering a move to classify
the controversial three minute film showing the hanging of Saddam Hussein, in
an effort to expose the hypocrisy and immorality of Australia's
National Classification Code and the state Classification Enforcement Acts.
Under the current system, the film depicting the
hanging of the former Iraqi dictator, (freely available on the internet), would
receive an R rating if submitted for classification and would then be available
to adults in all states of Australia, through family outlets like suburban
video libraries and petrol stations.
In stark contrast to this scenario, a film which
showed no violence or non-consent of any kind but only actual scenes of adult
sexuality was refused an R rating in a controversial decision by the
Classification Review Board (CRB) last month. The CRB's decisions and rationale
for classifying the film, Viva Erotica, have just been released (http://censorship.adultshop.com/files/folders/releases/entry284.aspx)
and it has stated that the film ‘would cause offence to a reasonable adult' and
therefore must carry the most restrictive X rating at a federal level and a ban
in every state. The film's distributor, Adultshop.com. - a listed company on
the Australian Stock Exchange - has vowed to take the issue into the Federal
Court (http://censorship.adultshop.com/Default.aspx).
Eros CEO, Fiona Patten said that the 1995 UK
film called Executions which showed a series of real-life,
state-sponsored executions, almost identical to the Saddam film, had been given
an R Rating by the Classification Board which had set a precedent for these
types of films. "The CRB is basically saying to the Australian public that the
film of Saddam's execution cannot be said to ‘cause offence to a reasonable
adult' while Viva Erotica can. This determination is so far from the
reality of what Australian public opinion is on these issues, that the federal
Attorney General needs to urgently intervene and conduct an enquiry", she said.
While not wanting to ban documentaries on any subject,
Ms Patten said that films depicting real murders or executions and real or
overly-intense simulated acts of violence, should be the most restricted films
under the current censorship scheme. Currently this is not the case because
films which show nonviolent and actual sex acts between consenting adults are
the most restricted and can draw fines and jail sentences for sale in all
states.
"State Attorney's General need to be aware of the fact
that they are supporting state regulation which could allow the Saddam film to
be sold from convenience stores while at the same time sending an adult shop owner
to jail for selling Viva Erotica through an adults-only premises", she
said. "This is not a popular or a logical approach to censorship in Australia
and defies every opinion poll ever carried out on the issue."
She also cautioned Federal Communications Minister,
Helen Coonan, about where she will draw the line on mobile phone content later
this month. "At present the Minister is indicating that she will allow adults
to download the hanging of Saddam Hussein and the film Executions on a mobile
phone with a PIN but not allow other adults to download Viva Erotica with
the same PIN. If she allows this regime to go ahead she will be telling the
Australian public to effectively ‘make war not love' and will reinforce the
notion within Australian youth that violence is somehow more acceptable or less
offensive than consenting sexuality".
Ms Patten said the issue was not about legalising
pornography but was about governments setting moral agendas that were truthful
and representative. "We all engage in sex acts throughout our adult lives", she
said. "But very few of us will be involved in killing or seriously assaulting
someone. Our censorship ratings should follow these sort of precepts and in
fact should mirror the criminal codes rather than the outmoded moral codes of
religious groups or the dictates of political extremists".
She called on the State and Commonwealth Attorney's
General to change the Classification Code to reflect killing and violence as
the most restricted depictions with non violent erotica and sex being less
restricted.
Fiona Patten
0413 734 613
PO Box 69 Deakin West
ACT 2600
Ph 02 6285 2477
Fax 02 6282 1499
www.eros.org.au
Download this media release here